Help this site

We need your help to get our message across! Send donations payable to International Viewpoint, PO Box 62732 London SW2 9GQ, Britain - or why not donate online:

Reader Survey

We want to improve International Viewpoint - to do this we need your feedback. Help us by spending a few minutes responding to our reader survey.

Editorial Policy

International Viewpoint is published under the responsibility of the Bureau of the Fourth International. Signed articles do not necessarily reflect editorial policy. Articles can be reprinted with acknowledgement, and a live link if possible.

Home > IV Online magazine > 2018 > IV520 - May 2018 > Israel adds a new chapter to the Nakba

Palestine

Israel adds a new chapter to the Nakba

Tuesday 22 May 2018

The Nakba isn’t forgotten history, but the inspiration for the continued resistance of millions of Palestinians in Gaza and around the world.

Seventy years ago, Israel was founded through the ethnic cleansing of
Palestine. Today, 70 years later, Israel continues to wage war on
Palestinians—driving them from their homes and denying them equal rights.

On May 14, as Israelis celebrated Donald Trump’s cruel provocation [1] in
relocating the U.S. embassy to Jerusalem, Palestinians in besieged Gaza came
out to protest an American president legitimizing the colonization of their
land—and to demand the right to return to the homes and land stolen from
them.

For that, they were massacred in cold blood. Israeli soldiers killed at least
55 Palestinians and injured more than 1,000, firing live ammunition into the
crowds.

Meanwhile, in Jerusalem, Israeli mobs harassed and assaulted Palestinians
protesting the U.S. embassy moving to a contested international city. Israeli
forces, aided by U.S. troops on the ground, confiscated Palestinian flags and
herded protesters like cattle.

As they watched unarmed Palestinian protesters beaten and arrested by
security forces, Israeli counterprotesters chanted [2] : "Burn them, shoot
them, kill them."

Meanwhile, the new U.S. embassy opened its doors in Jerusalem for the first
time. First family members Ivanka Trump and Jared Kushner, Treasury Secretary
Steven Mnuchin and U.S. Ambassador to Israel David Friedman attended the
ceremony.

Trump himself was missing from the scene, but made sure to send a video
celebrating the opening. Leading one of the prayers at the relocation
ceremony was Robert Jeffress, a Baptist pastor from Dallas, Texas, who has
referred to Islam [3] as "a heresy from the pit of hell."

May 15, the day after Israeli independence day, is the day that Palestinians
commemorate the Nakba, which means catastrophe in Arabic. It is the day that
Palestinians remember the 750,000 civilians forcibly displaced from their
homes and the more than 4 million acres of Palestinian land confiscated and
occupied by the fledging Israeli state.

The Zionist slogan prior to the founding of Israel [4] had been "a land
without a people for a people without a land." But in truth, Palestine had to
be /made/ into a land without a people.

So between March 31 and May 15, 1948, Zionist militias destroyed more than
200 Palestinian villages, perpetrated more than two dozen massacres [5], and
used terror to expel hundreds of thousands more Palestinians.

Today, 7 million Palestinians are forbidden from returning to their occupied
villages and towns. Though many live as refugees in neighboring countries or
as immigrants overseas, the majority of Palestinians live within miles of
their now-occupied homes.

Often framed as a religious war spanning millennia, the Nakba was, in fact,
the result of the late 19th-century political movement [6] that aimed to
cleanse Palestinians from their land in order to create a Jewish-majority
state in historic Palestine.

Israel has attempted to frame the Nakba as just one side of the story in a
two-sided conflict. In 2011, the Israeli Knesset passed the Nakba Law, which
penalizes public institutions receiving funding from the state for mourning
or commemorating the Nakba.

But no matter how hard Israel tries to erase the Nakba from memory, the
reality is that the state’s origins are inseparable from the brutality of
1948.

Trump’s decision back in December to move the U.S. embassy in Israel to
Jerusalem set off a series of protests around the world. Jerusalem has been
and continues to be a symbol of Palestinian sovereignty.

At the time of the announcement, an overwhelming majority of the United
Nations General Assembly voted against Trump’s decree, but this international
body holds little power to check the ambitions of a major imperialist state
like the U.S.

Although nearly 40 percent of Jerusalem’s population is Palestinian,
Palestinians are not afforded the right to vote, the right to buy land or the
right to build on land they possess. Palestinians in Jerusalem—as, indeed,
throughout Israel—live in a segregated society that discriminates against
them at every turn.

In Jerusalem, the streets are heavily militarized, the buses are segregated,
and places of worship frequented by Palestinians are barricaded with
checkpoints and numerous restrictions.

Although legally allowed to live anywhere in the city, the majority of
Palestinians are kept in East Jerusalem, where Israel has steadily been
revoking residency cards. Since 1967, nearly 15,000 Palestinian residents of
Jerusalem [7] have had their residency revoked.

It is clear that Trump’s announcement—and Israel’s enthusiasm for it—is a
provocation designed to bind the U.S. and Israel closer together as the two
countries, led by right-wing fanatics, embrace ethno-nationalism [8].

While this maneuver meshes neatly with Trump’s pandering to the constituency
of far-right Christian Zionists in the U.S., there’s more to it than that.

From the very first days of Trump’s presidency, he has time and again showed
his loyalty to the Israeli state, perhaps most clearly by his decision to
appoint his former bankruptcy attorney David Friedman [9] as U.S. ambassador
to Israel. Friedman used to serve as the president of the American Friends of
the Bet El Institutions, where he raised money to fund the construction of
illegal Jewish-only settlements [10] in the West Bank.

Other Trump appointees, like National Security Advisor John Bolton, also have
strong ties to the apartheid state. Indeed, Benjamin Netanyahu was right last
year when he said, "Israel does not have a better friend than Mr. Trump."

For years, Palestinians have been fighting against the expansion of Israel’s
settler-colonial project. The constant threat to Palestinians in
Jerusalem—from the revocation of residency cards to the innumerable
bureaucratic hoops Palestinians must go through to build homes, own land,
enroll in schools and visit their places of worship—is now magnified by the
embassy move.

In very concrete terms, Israel just relocated the building that represents
its biggest ally, military sponsor and partner in crime from the western edge
of its occupied lands to the very center. For anyone who still thinks that
either the U.S. or Israel plans to pursue a two-state solution, this move has
obliterated that flimsy illusion.

In his book /The Ethnic Cleansing of Palestine/, Israeli historian Ilan Pappe
cites primary material from the documents of the Hagana militia to reveal the
true designs of Israel’s founders.

Officers leading the seizure of Palestinian towns received clear instructions
to either "[destroy] villages (by setting fire to them, by blowing them up,
and by planting mines in their deris) and especially of those population
centers which are difficult to control continuously" or to besiege and search
Palestinian villages, with any armed resistance to be "wiped out and the
population expelled outside the borders of the state."

Between 1947 and 1948, the Hagana was given orders to instill fear and terror
in Palestinians in order to drive them out en masse. These orders were
carried out in dozens of villages and towns, leaving more than 400 villages
completely destroyed and hundreds of Palestinian men, women and children
massacred.

Then, as now, the powers backing the formation of the Israeli state cared
little about Palestinian lives. To them, the very existence of Palestinians
was a threat.

In place of these destroyed villages, Israel has built illegal settlements,
resorts, parks and other institutions Palestinians are barred from entering.
Yigal Allon, a military commander during the 1948 ethnic cleansing and later
a general in the Israel Defense Forces, was quoted in an early Israeli
leader’s diary as defending the indiscriminate killing of /all/ Palestinians:

>We need to be accurate about timing, place, and those we hit. If we accurse
>a family—we need to harm them without mercy, women and children included.
>Otherwise this is not an effective reaction. During the operation there is
>no need to distinguish between guilty and not guilty.
>
Seventy years after Allon said these words, Israel continues to apply his
strategy. In a statement following the release of a video depicting an
Israeli laughing and cheering [11]] as he shot unarmed Palestinians in Gaza,
Defense Minister Avigdor Lieberman insisted [12], "There are no innocent
people in Gaza."

Over the course of the last seven weeks, Israel has murdered at least 90
Palestinians in Gaza as they marched peacefully to demand their right of
return. More than 7,000 have been injured in these mass demonstrations.

After Trump’s announcement that the embassy would move to Jerusalem, Israel
waived numerous permits to expedite the construction of the new U.S.
building. The enthusiasm for Trump and his far-right political ideology has
been welcomed in Israel with open arms.

In Jerusalem over the course of the past few days, Jewish residents have been
parading in the streets of the city, waving Israeli flags; forcing their way
into the al-Aqsa compound, which is one of Islam’s holiest sites; and
celebrating both the annual flag day ceremony as well as the embassy move.

Jerusalem Mayor Nir Barkat announced last week on Facebook that a traffic
plaza near the embassy would be renamed "United States Square" [13] in honor
of Trump and his decree. A large sign near the embassy reads, "Trump, make
Israel great."

Since 1948, Israel has strengthened its expansionist project, incorporating
more Palestinian land under its control and subjecting Palestinians to a
brutal occupation. In fact, at the height of the so-called Oslo "peace
process" between 1993 and 2000, the number of illegal Jewish-only settlements
/doubled/.

In the last couple years, Israeli settlement construction has again risen
sharply, with an estimated 3,700 new settlement homes approved in 2018 alone
 [14].

These settlements are illegal under international law, according to the
Fourth Geneva Convention. However, just this month, the Israeli committee
tasked with legal issues pertaining to settlements built in the West Bank
released the Levy Report, officially called the Report on the Legal Status of
Building in Judea and Samaria. The 200-page report lays out detailed
proposals and recommendations for the legalization of Jewish-only settlements
built on Palestinian land.

At the heart of both the protests in Gaza and Trump’s decision to relocate
the U.S. embassy is a driving factor, viewed from opposite vantage points:
the struggle of Palestinians to demand their right of return.

More than anything, remembering the Nakba today is about confronting the fact
that Palestinians are illegally and unjustly prevented from returning to
their homes. Many Palestinians to this day hold the keys to properties from
which they were expelled.

This is why Palestinians are marching and dying in Gaza. And this is also
precisely why Israel expedited the move of the U.S. embassy. The more
Israel’s project expands, the more difficult it is for Palestinians and their
supporters to realize their just demands to return.

All the while, Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas and fellow
Palestinian elites are nowhere to be found.

Not a single one of the so-called Palestinian representatives released a
statement regarding Jerusalem in the days leading up to the embassy
relocation. Instead, most of these cabinet members were out of the country
during yesterday’s ceremony and massacre.

The Nakba is not a thing of the past. Its impact is felt by every single
Palestinian, and its memory shields against a systematic attempt to whitewash
the violence and bloodshed that characterized Israel’s birth 70 years ago,
and that sustains Israel’s apartheid regime today.

Claims that Palestinians are "violent," "terrorists" or a "security threat"
are more dubious than ever. What threat can children or the disabled possibly
pose to an advanced military and nuclear power? Why is the Palestinian
boycott, divestment and sanctions (BDS) movement—a nonviolent strategy for
attaining justice and accountability—criminalized more than the murder of
Palestinians?

The last seven weeks in Gaza are a reminder that no matter what Palestinians
do, they will be characterized as violent instigators. Their existence, no
matter how dismal, will be considered a threat—and their resistance a chance
to indiscriminately slaughter them.

The 55 Palestinians murdered yesterday—and the 49 others killed during the
Great Return marches—did not die in vain. While the Nakba is an ongoing
reality for millions of Palestinians, so is their resistance.

May 15, 2018

socialistworker.org

P.S.

If you like this article or have found it useful, please consider donating towards the work of International Viewpoint. Simply follow this link: Donate then enter an amount of your choice. One-off donations are very welcome. But regular donations by standing order are also vital to our continuing functioning. See the last paragraph of this article for our bank account details and take out a standing order. Thanks.